Summary
Spoiling hinders the development of emotional structure and autonomy by preventing children from having their own experiences and encouraging dependence and impulsivity. Parents can offer calm guidance without passing on their fears and seek professional guidance if they cannot stop being overprotective. When a son rejects his sister's Black boyfriend, possible influences from culture and the father's rigidity deserve consideration. Talking as a family without imposing opinions helps clarify wishes and objections and define a path everyone can respect, even if the outcome differs from expectations.
Source transcript
I am the eldest daughter among my mother's six children. For as long as I can remember, our family never had the custom of spoiling the children, until the arrival of my youngest brother, who is now twelve years old. My mother is obsessed with this boy and protects him as if he were made of porcelain. He cannot play in the street with the other boys because she says their games are aggressive and may hurt him. He cannot go anywhere alone, not even to the bakery on the corner of our street. He cannot do anything. Even today, she personally takes the boy to school and picks him up, which is a major ordeal for him because his little friends say, "Mommy is already here to pick you up; go with Mommy!" and he comes home crying.
This situation is very bad. My siblings and I have already spoken with my mother about it, but she does not accept that what she is doing is harmful to our little brother. We do not know what to do and would like your guidance, please; this is serious. A spoiled person, by being spoiled, does not develop sufficient defenses to have a happier life. A father often thinks he is protecting his child from life, from everything the father himself fears. I am not arguing that anyone should be plunged into suffering, but people need to have their own experiences.
Our life is divided into experiences from birth to age seven and from age seven to fourteen that mark our journey. During the first years, until age seven—or eight or nine—the child learns without defenses, receiving information and remaining open to the world. From age seven or eight onward, the child begins to confirm this information. If a person is extremely spoiled, they do not follow the natural course of forming their emotional structure and are left not knowing what to do, having neither learned nor confirmed it.
So it is a good idea to let our child have experiences. You can observe but should not tell the child how things must be. We can calmly guide the child on how to proceed in certain situations, without emotional charge, but without exerting the pressure people usually exert. We tend to tell a person, "Look, be careful with such-and-such," and the moment we say this, we already express all our fears, making thousands of recommendations that only increase the person's fear; the person will then lack the emotional structure to handle situations with clarity and discernment. Therefore, it is better to talk calmly, share a little about yourself without emotional charges, and be good-humored.
Say, "I am going to explain what happens," and clarify how this type of behavior works, which consists of overloading the person with threatening information; as a result, they receive no enlightening information, only threats.
There is an illustrative story: a son was sitting in the living room when he saw a little gecko on the wall; it went from one side to the other, moving quickly, and he watched it, played with it, and even gave it a name. Everything was fine until the little gecko went behind the picture. When the father arrived, the boy called him: "Look, Dad, come see this; it is so cute!" Upon seeing the little gecko, the father warned, "My son, do not go near that little gecko because it is poisonous; it may bite you, and we do not know what might happen." The little boy replied, "But how, Dad? My friends play with little geckos in their hands; I have a friend who has a little gecko like this and plays with it." He does not yet know the danger.
I am telling this because, from that point on, if the little boy were playing with something venomous or poisonous, the father could guide him: "Son, do not do that because it may be dangerous." The father's fear was transferred to the son not as information but as a charge of fear. The son will probably stop playing with the little gecko and, as an adult, will pass this fear on to those around him. In short, everything became confused; that is what I am talking about.
If you do not allow people to have their own experiences, you are telling them that they should not have their own life. Spoiling someone prevents that person from living autonomously. They begin copying others, desiring things they cannot have, and become unable to deal with their drives and investments. When they want something, they feel that they need to buy or possess it. This extremely impulsive woman pressures her husband to buy the handbags her friend has and, in the end, creates dysfunctional behavior that distances her from reality.
Reality is important. We are not here on this Earth simply to exist; we are here to grow and evolve. That is the overview we have. A spoiled person will go nowhere. They will spend their entire life with a great deal of suffering and conflict and, above all, receiving from others things they could do themselves. If you think your mother cannot break out of this, perhaps it would be a good idea to take her somewhere she can speak with a therapist or someone with good training in family relationships who can guide her.
The email says the following: my daughter is dating a very nice, hardworking, friendly person with no addictions, and I have no objection. The only thing is that we are of Asian descent, and he is a Black Brazilian. As my daughter's mother, I am not against this relationship, and neither is my husband. We accept him without any problem and talk with him without any discrimination. The greatest problem lies with my eldest son, who does not even greet my daughter's boyfriend when he arrives; he simply ignores his presence. He does not accept this at all.
On New Year's Eve, my daughter's boyfriend had dinner at my house, but my son did not even sit at the table to eat with us; he simply treated him with contempt, despite my asking him to sit so we could dine together. In addition, he told me that if the situation continued, he would leave home and live elsewhere, without her boyfriend knowing, of course. I was very sad because I do not know how to get around this. I have not spoken with my husband about the situation and do not know whether he noticed it; I believe he did not because he is very distant from my children. There is no dialogue; he does not talk with them. You know how it is: a present father, an absent father. Curiously, however, he chats with other people, including my daughter's boyfriend. Is there any guidance or suggestion for improving this environment somewhat?
What can I do so that my son matures and realizes that what he is doing is childish, immature, and prejudiced behavior? I am afraid to say this to my son. If he rebels against me, it will create an uncomfortable situation; after all, what should I do?
There was someone who was my friend—he has died—who was also of Asian origin. He was married to a woman of Japanese origin. His wife's sister was dating a Black person. He felt uncomfortable and said, "Wow, I keep trying to please people because they have different customs." On one side was his wife's entire family, who were all Japanese—and when Japanese people hold a celebration, an enormous number of people come. On the other side was the Black family, which also included many people.
It became something that offered little room for conversation, in part because people of Japanese origin have another culture and other differences. The conversation is different, and the food is different. He mentioned this to me. Now, upon receiving this email, I find myself thinking that it is not so simple because people may or may not accept it.
When you say that your son has a certain difficulty with this, perhaps talking with him will not be so easy. Why does he not accept it? What is happening? He may truly discriminate. The path to a solution is not always simple. It would be a good idea to sit down and talk with him, involving all family members, to make the situation as good as possible through a conversation. There may be paths you do not yet see, and your son may even say that if it is this way, you can accept it, try to reconcile, or make an effort.
I do not know exactly how your family was constituted or whether your son is subject to very rigid rules or to the culture. Culture ends up influencing people's lives a great deal. You also say that your husband does not talk with anyone. What you describe is the reality of a type of behavior: at home, the husband is extremely rigid with everyone, demands a great deal from everyone, and is very exacting; however, when he goes out, his relationship with people is quite flexible and relaxed, and he presents himself differently, exactly as everyone at home would like to relate to him.
He will listen to the person, laugh, play, and tell jokes, and then at home he completely changes how he expresses himself. It would be good to determine whether this behavior by your husband affects your son's rigidity: he may be rigid at home, and then your son also becomes very rigid. How will you deal with this? He will adopt closed positions, become inflexible, and leave you very little room to resolve the issue.
For this reason, it would be a good idea to bring the family together. Gather everyone and discuss the matter with the intention of resolving it. The point is not to impose anyone's opinion but to talk and achieve the best possible outcome. This best outcome may differ from what we expect. Yet I think a good outcome is one that allows a path forward to be defined, so that everyone clearly understands that an option was chosen and that this option must be respected.
Even if he says, "Look, if this continues, I will not stay at home," perhaps that is his wish. First, it would be good to sit down and talk to clarify what is happening, what he thinks, what his wishes are, what he does not accept, and so on. With this information, it may be possible to find some paths forward. It is a decision in one person's life, in your daughter's life, in your life, and in the family's life. Try talking first.
Questions raised by this material
- How does overprotection affect children's emotional development?
- How can parents guide their children without passing on their own fears?
- How can you discuss racial prejudice in the family without imposing your views?
- How does parental strictness influence children's behavior?
Keywords
How to cite
Esagüi, M. (2021, October 6). Is Spoiling Bad? [Audio podcast episode]. Center for Consciousness Studies. https://centrodeestudos.org/en/library/is-spoiling-bad/





